Wednesday, August 4, 2021

Spiritually Speaking: It’s all the Same to me Book Review

It's all the same to me by Moshe Gersht
What meaning do you give and assign to your life and to life in general? Regardless of how much or how little a role spirituality, religion or philosophy may play in your personal life, the way you view your life and that of others will profoundly affect the way you act and interact with yourself and others. It does not matter what religion you profess, practice, or follow, nor whether you are an agnostic or an atheist; whether you notice and acknowledge this or not, you have a mindset that will shape and mold your views and experiences.

There are many self-help books out there and many books that contain spiritual outlooks, guidance, and guidelines, and yet, they tend to have a specific agenda. This is why in many cases and situations, people grow wary and suspicious and move and turn away from organized religion as it seems to be a carnival or a fair of toothpaste vendors vying and competing with each other on how and why their brand is the better, superior, and the best for your teeth, i.e. soul.

Their feelings and experiences may or may not be in earnest, they may or may not have an authentic connection to spirituality, and yet, we always feel or find it hard and challenging to shake off the feeling that we are being sold something or, even worse, that we are being tricked and conned in one way or another. This feeling is much stronger nowadays where state and religion are not as distinct and segregated as it used to be and where the realms of politics and government have been intentionally and heavily politicized for different reasons and purposes.

And it is rare to find a book that talks plainly and openly about God and does not feel dogmatic and does not try to sell you something or to convert you to their side. In fact, when reading Moshe Gersht’s outstanding book It’s all the Same to me: A Torah Guide to Inner Peace and Love of Life, I felt like entering a holy space of profound understanding and living. The space did not feel unfamiliar to me; it resonates with me, and I can vouch for its truth, honesty, and integrity, and yet, although our destination is the same, my path has been a very different one.

As the book shows and tells us, there is a point at which all things converge and where spirituality emerges in one and the same flowing river. Moshe uses the wisdom of the Torah and brings out and crystalizes its light and holiness, whereas my path is a bit more eclectic consisting of an odd, personalized mix and hybrid of religion, philosophy, and psychology, and yet, the end result and experience are one and the same and ring as true as gold.

But what is spirituality if not one common state and experience that deep inside we all share and agree with? We may not know what it is and perhaps not even agree why it is, but we all know on a deep intuitive level how it is: It is one of those things where we say to ourselves, I know when I see it, and I do see it and recognize it in this wonderful little book. 

Moreover, I respect the author’s eclectic experiences and path: It is written by an ex-member of a punk band who decided to first wet his toes and then fully immerse himself in a spiritual bath of some sorts by studying closely and then living and practicing intimately the Torah, Kabbalah, Chassidus, and Spirituality in the quest for Divine inspiration and clarity.

It is part and parcel of a collective unconscious or consciousness that brings to light our essence and true self in all its glory, brightness, and shining colors. This also comes with profound joy, a joy that is not based on ephemeral things that do not matter in the grand scheme of things but that is rooted in the innocent, profound, and knowing smile and laughter of a child. 

It is the infinite light that shines through all and everything and that reminds us that despite our differences, we are all connected and the same. Different and yet the same was a mantra I remember from Buddhist teachings, and it is chiseled and filtered out brilliantly and diligently in this book.

The eternal truth flowing through all of existence cannot be owned and possessed, nor modified nor changed, but it is as it is; it is indeed patiently and lovingly waiting for you to recognize it and to connect to it regardless of your religious and cultural background or experience of life. 

It is the ultimate reality that is beyond physical, mental, and emotional reality. It is a life lived to the fullest that is devoid of negative beliefs and frames of mind. It is a spiritual mindset shaped within the oneness and stillness of God’s/Buddha’s mind.

Enlightenment is the state of light and weightlessness. You lighten the load by becoming empty, the way Meister Eckhart speaks of the empty vessel to be filled with the loving essence and nature of God. Enlightenment is two-fold, the divine spark il-luminating itself to vivid and vibrant light, and it is, at the same time, becoming light in terms of weight, so you can float three inches above the ground in everything you say or do, including seemingly mundane activities like doing the dishes or brushing your teeth. This epiphany will lead to inner peace, lasting joy, and endless and boundless love.

In this peace and understanding, you will not trick or delude yourself but rather see and accept the world as it is; you will be able to express, in Moshe’s words, “conviction without anger, strength without negativity, and confidence without arrogance”. It is also a life lived and experienced and transformed by ideas that emanate from a divine source, pointing and reaching toward a truth that is beyond reason and an essence that is beyond one’s limited ego.

It may start with the question of why but must look beyond the answers that are provided by dramatic narratives; those ego-infected stories accentuate pain and suffering, while the negative energy associated with them will drive us further away from the wells of happiness already contained deep within us. According to Moshe, the answer is based on the here and now and begins with Hishtavus - close kin and ally to the Tao - a state of nonjudgmental awareness in which we accept reality as it is without labeling it as something or other.

It is a conscious alignment with a higher order of the universe that is based on harmony in accordance with all life and all sentient beings, a life that is “God in action” aligned and connected with living in the presence of God: It is Ekyeh Asher Ekyeh, which stands for “I am that I am” or “I will be Who I will be”. Our mind and our senses can only see, perceive, and conceive of a fraction of life and truth, but an inner knowing can guide us in the direction of this unspoken and unseen truth.

Hishtavus comes with allowing ourselves as well as things to be and unfold as they will and do and surrendering not by giving up but by letting go of expectations of how you think things should and ought to be. This does not mean repressing oneself or one’s emotions, and it certainly is not a form of denial. As Moshe observes, emotions are real, but they are not reality itself. In fact, they often lead to the distortion of reality.

By not putting artificial labels on our experiences, by resisting that ingrained habit and temptation, we can become free of them. Hence, they cannot influence and sway us into negativity or into negative and repetitive patterns of thoughts and behavior. In other words, this can be best expressed and defined in the words of Judith Orloff as emotional freedom.

It comes with an attitude, an affirmation, and a profound piece of wisdom, an inner yes. It is an all-pervasive and all-inclusive attitude of nonattachment and nonresistance to the ever-flowing flow of life. It is a deliberate and willful choice and one that values peace and acceptance over denial and resistance. 

By seeing and processing life’s events through and with a different lens, you can gain a perspective that is devoid of anger, resentment, and negative energy. Instead of cursing your life or luck, you can see and transform life’s difficulties into a challenge, an opportunity for growth and understanding - and for empathy.

As Moshe astutely observes, this will lead you to not only feel better about yourself and the whole situation, but it will also help you to make better decisions, which will have repercussions not only for yourself but for everyone else within your circle. Your anger and anxiety would diminish or even vanish completely, and you will not see problems but rather situations.

A problem is simply something that did not go according to plan, or rather, your perception of how things ought to be or should have been. A problem can be something you do not wish to happen, or you feel anxious that it may be potentially happening in the future. Yet in a spiritual mindset, you do not see failure as limiting and debilitating, rather you see it as empowering; you take advantage of the chance and opportunity that come with it by harnessing and channeling its potential towards greater success.

But it is more than a mindset as it is based on higher consciousness. For instance, Moshe’s personal experiences of being a lead singer in a rock/pop-punk band eventually ended up paving the way toward a spiritual path that would bring him peace and joy in his life. It was a steppingstone that led him and moved him forward in aiming and reaching for his spiritual potential. Life, he claims, is not happening to you, but it is happening for you.

There is no escape here; it is built on full acceptance of the pain and suffering that comes with it. We must not evade or run away from our feelings but fully experience them. It is being mindful of everything that comes our way, including our emotional and physical pain. And yet, this stance, attitude, and willingness will help us deeply embrace and love all of life.

The voice of the ego, the Yetzer Hara, the creative force that is undeveloped and immature, is the false and deluding sense of self, and it is the disconnect between us, life, reality, and God. By freeing oneself from this limiting and limited view of oneself, one can gain independence, freedom as well as peace and joy.

Here is where Buddhism and the Torah intersect again: the Buddhist saying of “If you see the Buddha, kill him” is mirrored and reflected in the Torah’s “What should a person do if they want to live? Kill yourself.” It is the conscious decision of not desperately holding onto a drop when there is an endless ocean all around you embedded within the richness of the sea of life.

It is pure humility and living sameness; it is all the same once you can look past the narrow limits set by the ego’s attachment of wanting more, needing to be always right, complaining, always being on the run and rarely pausing to engage in rewarding and energizing wu-wei, the Taoist act of non-doing.

There is much more to cover and explore in this book, but instead, I shall provide two alternate ways of dealing with one common issue and problem: traffic. Let us assume that you have an important meeting coming up and that you have planned everything in advance and have given yourself ample time and legroom to make it on time.

You even got up an hour earlier than usual and are confident that nothing can get into your way now. And yet, there was a car accident that brought traffic to a complete standstill, and you will be at least half an hour late for this important and essential meeting of yours.

 

Scenario 1: The (more common) Angry Route

You curse your luck. Why does it always have to happen to you and why does it happen on the day where you have an important meeting! It seems that the universe has conspired against you. Now you must face your controlling boss and all your co-workers, and they will think that you are an irresponsible and unprofessional person.

As you are inching forward at a snail’s pace, you swear left and right at all the cars and drivers around you. You arrive at work and walk into the office complaining about the traffic. The meeting goes badly, and you snap at everyone around you and want to give your boss the finger.

Then you go home, and you are so angry and upset that you do not play with your son; you have dinner and only complain about your crappy day. You also get into a fight with your wife while you are at it, and it is all about trifles that did not matter yesterday and will not matter tomorrow. You cannot fall asleep and are worried about the next day.

 

Scenario 2: The Hashtivus Way (or the less traveled path of least resistance)

You tried but nobody is perfect. There is a traffic jam. Now you can listen to the Arash’s World podcast you were always curious about. As you are inching your way ahead, you note all the angry faces and all the instances of road rage.

You arrive and the first thing you do is apologize for being late. You thank everyone for being patient with you, and with a smile, you give your presentation. In fact, you do a slightly better job because you were relaxed all the way and you had a bit more time to practice and rehearse it in the car before arriving. Even your grumpy mean boss cannot help but be impressed with your stoic demeanor and stamina.

You arrive home and know that there was really nothing and no reason to worry or feel angry about it. You can do without that extra shroud of negativity. You listen carefully to what your son has to tell you, and then you tell your wife at dinner that despite the cards seemingly stacked against you, you managed to do a relatively impressive job at work. You go to sleep with a smile anticipating the next day.

***

It is certainly not easy to pick the second route. In fact, it takes a lot of practice, willpower, and discipline. But it is worth it because anger and worry will certainly not help you. You know that nobody is perfect and that there are some things that are simply not in our control. You know that failure is necessary for growth and that it is “better to try and fail than fail to try”. Moreover, stress waves will appear, but you remain a beacon of inner stillness and joyful confidence, the stillness of the bottom of the ocean that remains unperturbed by the splashing waves above.

The universe is saying to you: “I will be whatever you want me to be. I’ll treat you how you treat me” because the place upon which you stand is holy ground. You have a spiritual mindset and tune into the loving vibration of the universe, and deep in your heart, your emotional epicenter, you know that cosmos means order. All roads may not lead to Rome but there are indeed various paths that can lead to the same outcome. Whether you opt for Hashtivus or the Tao, Zen, Sufism, or Christian mysticism, spiritually speaking, they are all the same to you.

No comments: